2) True Be or Not True Be

Both players prepare two stories and write them on two separate index cards. Each story should be a life event that is only 1-2 sentences long, but one of them is not true yet still believable. Decide who will tell their story first and the other will pick which index card to read. After the story is read, their opponent has 60 seconds to ask as many questions as they can in hopes to determine if they are lying or telling the truth. Once the minute is up, a final decision is made and the person telling the story reveals whether it was true or not. Switch roles and play again!
Can be found in S1E01 starting at 18:32, S1E05 starting at 6:08, S1E10 starting at 18:51 AND S3E03 starting at 12:56